". . . a brush with nature"

8/7/2015 12:03:18 PM

Put to the Test

Debbie Hughbanks / 17 Comments

"American Goldfinch" - pastel on Pastel Premier Italian Clay Painting Surface
"American Goldfinch" - pastel on Pastel Premier Italian Clay Painting Surface

Finally I may have found a new pastel surface I might actually come to love. After having a favorite sanded paper I worked exclusively on for years I was devastated to learn it was no longer available anywhere. This happened quite some time ago and since I had a “stash” of my own I simply placed my name on waitlists in anticipation of when the product did become available. Months and then years went by and that never happened. Of course, I eventually depleted my own supply and then went on a shameless mission of bartering with other pastelists for any pieces, large or small, of this museum grade paper they might be willing to part with. In the meantime I tried paper after paper . . . surface after surface . . . some with minimal success and others a dismal failure due to the way I like to work. So as you might imagine, when I was recently given three workable size samples of yet another pastel painting surface to try, I wasn’t holding out much hope . . . however, I decided to really put it to the test.

I wanted something I could do an underpainting on if I desired. I was assured that Pastel Premier Italian Clay would stand up to it, so I took my sample and applied not one watercolor wash, but three. After that, I rigorously blotted and wiped to see what happened. Hmmm . . . . so far so good.  Then I moved on to my pastels. I wanted a surface with quite a lot of “tooth” to hold multiple layers of pastel. Starting with the background I applied layer after layer working with each brand of pastels I have. Everything still seemed to be going quite well from the technical end of this experiment except that I really didn’t care for the colors at all. I decided to remove the pastel I had placed and start afresh. I rubbed the pastel off with a rag secretly doubting there would be much surface left there to work with. Still with some level of doubt I started in reworking the painting using multiple layers of pastels and pastel pencils. Now for the real test, I thought. On my “old favorite” I had been able to tap the back to release loose pastel before spraying. That NEVER worked on any of the other papers or surfaces I have tried since. With some trepidation (and holding my breath) I held the painting up and tapped. What? The loose dust released, but the work was still there! (That was huge, because last year I lost about six hours of work when I tried this with another surface. I’d been assured that sanded paper was just what I was looking for and that it could withstand everything the “old favorite” could. Apparently that was not so. Needless to say, I was not a happy artist that day. )

The final test would be spraying the work. I have used a high quality (expensive) pastel spray for a number of years and was always pleased with it when used in conjunction with my previous favorite surface. I didn’t experience the color shift so many artists speak of when spraying and I was always satisfied that my work was protected for framing and shipping purposes. However, when spraying on some other surfaces lately unusual things have happened. The strangest being the complete loss of blues and greens on a rather large piece after spraying. Yikes! I still cannot explain what happened there, however you could see completely down to the paper where the water and trees were, but everything else was fine. Perhaps it is a subject for a different blog on a different day . . . but needless to say, I brought out the pastel spray with great hesitation. If I could have sprayed this piece with my eyes closed I would have. I couldn’t bear to look, but in the end even this part of the experiment went fine.

Granted, I have only created one small pastel painting on Pastel Premier Italian Clay, but so far I am very excited about this pastel painting surface. It is 100% cotton archival quality and I believe that might be the big difference. Of course, I am going to have to work on it much more before saying unequivocally that I am “in love” with it totally and unconditionally, but as of today I am very, very impressed!

Thank you Dakota Pastels for the sample piece to try!

 

 

Share This Post


Comments

17 Responses to Put to the Test

I love the new direction, the Birds and the writing behind just Fantastic, you will be winning more and more awards. I Love your new idea.

Lovely painting! What do you use to do the writing? I have some poems that I would like to put behind a painting.

Carolyn, thank you for the kind comment on my painting. I used a combination of pastel pencils and colored pencils for the lettering on this piece and the others in this series.
Best of luck with you piece. It sounds wonderful!

I've also been devastated by Wallis withdrawals! but, so happy to have learned on it. Luckily, the slow supply prompted me to buy everything oatmeal before supplies stopped.
Light at the end of a tunnel? I saw this paper online. It was my first glint of hope and wonder. I did a search to find out more and your review was exactly what I needed. I'm placing my order today and getting out my pastels in time for the North Carolina Statewide Juried Pastel Exhibition! I can't wait to wash on my alcohol/water watercolor underpainting and scumble luscious layers of pastel on top! Oh, the delight to practice what Teresa Saia, my masterful instructor I titled "The Queen of Scumble," taught me in the 2015 NCSJPE workshop. Thanks, Debbie! I will follow your blog.
What grit was most similar to Wallis?

Hi Nancy. So nice to hear about your experiences with pastels and Wallis and your enthusiasm about trying this new paper and all the new techniques you learned in the workshop. I can feel your excitement! The grit I specifically referenced in my blog was the Italian Clay Medium (320-400 grit). I have copied here what the company itself recommends regarding underpainting . . . specifically regarding the use of alcohol - "The paper works with a wide range of wet media including water, mineral spirits, and alcohol (heavy use of alcohol NOT recommended - may soften surface) for under-painting." You read what I did to this paper and I have used it for many pieces since. I am still very happy with it. Best of luck . . . and enjoy!

Today Michele Aplin told me about this Premier paper while I was ordering pastels Girault and complaining about the unavailability of Kitty Wallis paper
I saw your blog on the Dakota website. Your experience is similar to mine. I have spent the last several years developing a method of painting using watercolor gouache and ink with pastel on Wallis paper. I have just about exhausted my supply and have been feeling like a lost puppy. Uart and the others don't cut it. Now I see hope. Are you still on board with it? I appreciate your post.

Hi Kraig! Thank you for reading my blog and for sharing your very similar experiences with me. I certainly understand how you feel. I AM still on board with Pastel Premier paper and continue to be quite happy with the results I am achieving with each new piece. I hope you enjoy it as much as I have and I wish you much success with it.

I have done a lot of work on pastel premiere. I really like the texture of it and the effect of doing an underpainting, then lightly brushing pastel over it. It's great for stone walls and anything with texture. I have used the white and the clay. I have not dry-mounted it and I've found that use of watercolor makes it warp a bit. I have used alcohol with no problem, which doesn't make it warp. The one problem that I've had is with using the hard pastels for the underpainting. The surface doesn't seem to accept more than one layer. The second application knocks off the first! This is very frustrating, as I like to use multiple colors in my underpaintings. I have noticed the same thing with the rougher UART paper as well. However, once I move to Girault and the softer pastels, they stay on beautifully. The clay is a particularly nice color to work on. I have not used the others. I used to have students use Belgian mist Wallis as they could build up many layers with the cheaper NuPastels. This doesn't seem to be possible with Premiere due to its consistency.

Hi Jean! Thank you for sharing your experiences. It is always good to find out what other artists are doing - what works for them and what doesn't.
I am still very pleased with this surface; I do apply multiple layers of pastel and underpaintings using watercolor or acrylic . I have never tried the NuPastels, however, so it is good to learn of your experiences with them. I, too, use Girault and the softer pastels with much success and satisfaction.

hopefully you keep up with Kitty Wallis on FB- she is pouring through the final shipment, inspecting qualify, and continues to note on FB when paper is available. I think currently she only has Belgian mist or warm Belgian, but do contact her.

Hi Liz! Thanks for reading my post and for your comment. I have enjoyed using the paper you mentioned in the past. However, when I started working with an underpainting on so many of my pastel pieces I needed something that could withstand the watercolor wash, blotting and all the other paces I put the paper through. At the time, the product you mentioned was not recommended for this type of usage.

Hi,
I just wanted to thank you for your helpful post about the Pastel Premier paper.
I've done pastels on many different surfaces, and have also tried the pastel premier. I like it, and now
will try working on it more consciously and carefully.

thanks again!

Barbara Stein

Thanks for reading my blog and your comments, Barbara! I am glad to hear you have tried and enjoyed this surface, too. Here's to many more enjoyable hours and successful pieces working with it! - Debbie

Hi, I too am searching for a new strong paper to underpaint. I do a lot of blending of hills and
especially clouds (my specialty). So I am wondering what this will do to my fingers !
OR does this paper work with a soft rag to blend?

I really love the effect you got with the bird. I do similar animals and just need a paper that will show
various textures, eg: fur, feathers and such.

Thanks again for your info and experience !

Cathi from Minnesota.

I am just seeing this for the first time. I use underpaintings frequently, particularly using UART 400 or 320 paper that has been premounted. I purchase boards from TruGrit Pastel panels and love them. Lately, I am purchasing the 320 and like it better than the 400. It can take almost anything in the way of an underpainting.
I saw a comment that mentioned "the bird" and I am assuming that this refers to my painting called "Keeping Watch." This was done on a completely different surface. It was a pastelbord that I had painted with another painting and washed off. Then I resurfaced it with two coats of toned Art Spectrum Colourfix liquid primer (clear, toned with liquid acrylic). I drew on the composition then added watercolor as a further toning. Then painted directly on it. When I use this surface, I consider it to be a "toned" surface, not and "underpainted" surface. I LOVE what it does for me, particularly when painting difficult areas such as streets with snow (see my painting Shore Houses in Winter).
I hope that this has been useful to you.

Hi Cathi! Thank you for reading my blog and for your kind comments about my goldfinch. I really appreciate them! I think you will be fine blending your hills and clouds with your fingers because that is how I almost always do all my blending, too. I do not have any reason to expect this surface wouldn't work with a soft rag, however I haven't tried it very often myself. Pastel Premier really has stood up well to everything I have tried with it and I am still extremely happy with it even these many months (and pieces) later.

Hi Jean! Thank you for visiting and posting on my blog about my experiences with Pastel Premier once again. It is always good to hear about and share other artist's experiences with working surfaces and techniques. Thank you for sharing yours.


Leave a Comment

Remember Your Info
Check this box if you want email updates when people comment on this post